Translation commentary on Judges 1:26

This verse could be considered as the next event on the story line or as a kind of aside. It tells how another city of Luz was founded, tying back to verse 1.23.

And the man went to the land of the Hittites: The conjunction And introduces the next thing the man from Bethel did after he was let go. A conjunction such as “so” (Contemporary English Version) or “then” (New International Version) might also be appropriate here. Although only the man is mentioned, obviously he had his family with him. The verb went is used to describe the man’s escape. The man had to get far enough away to prevent retribution for his act, since he would certainly be considered as a traitor to his own people.

The Hittites were originally from the northeast region of modern Turkey. These people were of Indo-European rather than Semitic origin, but at times the two peoples came into contact. In Gen 23, for example, Abraham bought a field from a Hittite named Ephron. One of David’s soldiers, the husband of Bathsheba, was also a Hittite (verse 2 Sam 11.3). Some of the Hittites had migrated south from their homeland into Canaan, so the land of the Hittites may not have been too far away.

The Hebrew says he built a city, which means he “founded a city” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh). Languages may have idiomatic expressions for founding a village or town which can be used here.

And called its name Luz: Luz was the original name of the town of Bethel (see verse 1.23). The man named this new town with the original name of his hometown. Renaming new towns with the name of old ones was a common practice in this region. The word Luz sounds like the Hebrew word for “almond tree.”

For that is its name to this day, see verse 1.21. We might say “People continue to call it Luz to this day.”

Translation models for this verse might be:

• The man moved to Hittite territory and established a town that he called Luz, which remains its name till today.

• The man and his family went to where the Hittites lived. He began a settlement there that he called Luz. People continue to call it by that name [till now].

Quoted with permission from Zogbo, Lynell and Ogden, Graham S. A Handbook on Judges. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2019. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Judges 1:27

The information in this verse and the next one can also be found in verse 17.11-13. Even if a new paragraph begins here, this is a continuation of the story of the house of Joseph (verse 1.22-26). This verse begins with the Hebrew waw conjunction, which Revised Standard Version and most other English versions omit. However, if the story is allowed to flow from 1.26, this conjunction might be rendered “But” (New International Version).

Manasseh did not drive out the inhabitants …: Manasseh was the older of Joseph’s two sons (see Gen 48). He became the ancestor of one of the tribes of Israel, with Gideon being one of his tribe’s most famous heroes. Manasseh’s territory was in the area west of the Jordan River and north of Shechem, extending up to Megiddo Pass. However, the tribe spread out to live on both sides of the Jordan River. As with the other singular names in this section, Manasseh refers not to that individual, but to his descendants or his clan.

For did not drive out, see the discussion at verse 1.19. Revised English Bible uses the expression “failed to drive out,” repeated throughout this section. This wording is an effective way to emphasize that the various tribes failed to do what the LORD asked. For inhabitants see verse 1.11.

Five towns are mentioned here: Beth-shean, Taanach, Dor, Ibleam, and Megiddo, along with their villages. Some of these towns are known, especially Megiddo. All must have been wealthy cities and may have been important because of their proximity to various trade routes.

And its villages is literally “and its daughters,” obviously underlining all the places this tribe was unable to dominate. “Daughters” refers to the areas where those towns spread out. Often small communities settled around big towns, profiting from their protection and commercial contacts. Some languages do not have separate words for “city,” “town,” and “village,” so translators may have to find other means to express this notion. We may render its villages as “its settlements,” “its communities,” “people living near the town,” or “in the surrounding territory.”

Revised Standard Version follows the Hebrew text closely with its repetitive the inhabitants of … and its villages. This repetition gives emphasis, but the translator may reduce it if necessary. Good News Translation lists the five towns and then adds the phrase “and the nearby towns.” Contemporary English Version is similar with “the towns of Beth-Shan, Taanach, Dor, Ibleam, Megiddo, and all the villages nearby.”

But the Canaanites persisted in dwelling in that land: This sentence is quite emphatic and underlines not only the inability of the Israelites to dominate these peoples, but also the forceful determination of the Canaanite peoples. But, rendering the Hebrew waw conjunction, may express contrast here, but in many languages this conjunction may sound unnatural. Many English versions do not translate it (Good News Translation, Contemporary English Version, Revised English Bible, New Jerusalem Bible, New American Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh), but we might say “In fact,” “and,” or even “because” (see New International Version “for”).

The Canaanites put up strong resistance to the invasion by Manasseh’s soldiers. The Hebrew term for Canaanites is singular, but has a collective meaning here (see verse 1.1). Persisted in dwelling means the Canaanites “were determined to stay” (Contemporary English Version) or “held their ground” (New Jerusalem Bible). Good News Translation‘s “continued to live” is not strong enough here. In dwelling translates the Hebrew infinitive for the verb occurring first in verse 1.9 and throughout this book. In that land is emphatic in Hebrew, with the word for land (ʾerets) being the same one used throughout the Old Testament to refer to the Promised Land. However, here we may simply say “in that territory” or “in that region,” or we may replace the phrase with a pronominal expression such as “there” (Good News Translation).

A possible model for this verse is:

• But Manasseh did not succeed in driving out the people who lived in the towns of Beth-shean, Taanach, Dor, Ibleam, and Megiddo, nor the villages surrounding them. Indeed, the Canaanites were determined to stay there.

Quoted with permission from Zogbo, Lynell and Ogden, Graham S. A Handbook on Judges. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2019. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Judges 1:28

When Israel grew strong: This verse begins with two key Hebrew expressions wayehi ki (“And it was that when”), which show a possible time lapse, as well as a new paragraph. Translators can look for an appropriate transition, for example, “Later on” or “But some time later.” We might also say “And when” (New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh), “But when” or “As.” For Israel see verse 1.1. This verse seems to be a summary statement applying to all of the tribes.

The Hebrew verb rendered grew strong has various meanings but here refers to the Israelites gaining strength militarily or becoming stronger in number. Many versions say “grew stronger” (New American Bible; similarly Good News Translation, New Jerusalem Bible). Contemporary English Version‘s “grew more powerful” correctly implies that at first they were not strong enough to subjugate the Canaanites, but later became so. New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh’s “gained the upper hand” is possible but seems to put too much emphasis on political power. At this point in their history, the tribes of Israel seem to be loosely connected, joined by alliances. Some believe the tribes of Israel formed a kind of federation, but certainly there were no formal structures to speak of during that time period.

They put the Canaanites to forced labor indicates an important change in the relationship between the Israelites and the Canaanite population. This expression follows the Hebrew quite literally and is repeated throughout the section (verse 1.28, 30, 33, 35).

Forced labor refers to work that people are obliged to carry out by the authorities in control. Though in some situations forced labor is considered a contribution toward the payment of taxes, while in other cases it borders on slavery. The notion of forced labor will be known in many cultures around the world, especially where colonial powers once ruled, and thus there will be idiomatic expressions to express this reality. If not, we can simply say “they forced the Canaanites to work for them.” New International Version says “they pressed the Canaanites into forced labor,” while New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh translates “they subjected … to forced labor,” which are both good models. Contemporary English Version‘s “they made slaves of the Canaanites” may be too specific. Translators need to be cautious using the word “slave” here and elsewhere in translation, as types of forced labor and slavery may differ considerably throughout the world.

For the first two clauses of this verse, we might say:

• Later when the Israelites became more powerful, they obliged the Canaanites to work for them.

• But later on, the Israelites grew stronger, so they pushed the Canaanites into forced labor.

But did not utterly drive them out: Here and elsewhere the text does not say whether the Israelites were unable to drive out these peoples or whether they simply chose not to do it. As they became stronger, they may have been able to drive them out, but perhaps chose not to do so. Certainly the Canaanites had now become a source of cheap labor and the two cultures may have also begun to merge.

But (Hebrew waw conjunction) introduces an unexpected event. Even though the Israelites became strong, they did not obey the LORD by removing the Canaanites. We might say “nevertheless,” “still,” or “however.”

The Hebrew expression rendered did not utterly drive them out is a forceful one, using a compound verb construction that is literally “driving out, they did not drive them out.” There is heavy emphasis on the fact that the people of Israel failed to do what Yahweh had requested of them. This is the theological justification for the fact that other peoples dominated Israel during the Judges period. Translators need to find a very strong expression, such as “they never did completely drive them out” or “they never did completely remove the Canaanites from the land.” For drive … out, see verse 1.19.

Quoted with permission from Zogbo, Lynell and Ogden, Graham S. A Handbook on Judges. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2019. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Judges 1:29

And Ephraim did not drive out the Canaanites who dwelt in Gezer: And renders the Hebrew waw conjunction, which seems to link back to what precedes. Interestingly, this conjunction does not introduce the information occurring with the tribes mentioned in the following verses (verse 1.30, 31, 33). Certainly this link is due to the fact that Manasseh and Ephraim were brothers and their names almost always appear together. Since a negative clause follows this conjunction, in some languages negative introductory words such as “Neither” or “Nor” might be used here.

Ephraim was the second son of Joseph, but his descendants became more famous than those of his older brother, Manasseh. Indeed, this tribe became so important that the name Ephraim began to be used to refer to the entire northern kingdom of Israel, located in the central hills between Manasseh and Benjamin. Its territory extended north from Bethel to Shechem and from the Jordan River down to the Mediterranean Sea. The words rendered Ephraim and Canaanites both occur in the singular in Hebrew, but as usual refer to a collective plural. For did not drive out, see verse 1.19.

The town of Gezer was located on the southern border of Ephraim’s territory, in the lowlands toward the coast. The Israelites captured this city and killed its king (verse 10.33; verse 12.7, 12). Though there were many important cities in Ephraim, Gezer is the only one cited here. This is probably due to its importance and wealth. During the time of Solomon, the king of Egypt captured this city and gave it to his daughter as a wedding present when she married Solomon. Later, Solomon rebuilt the city (verse 1 Kgs 9.15-17).

But the Canaanites dwelt in Gezer among them: But, which renders the Hebrew waw conjunction, seems slightly out of place. Some versions omit the conjunction altogether. Good News Translation and New American Bible provide a good transition with “and so.” For dwelt see verse 1.9. Dwelt … among them implies that the Canaanites lived together with the Israelites, but unlike the previous verse, here there is no mention of persistence. It might be helpful to say they “continued to reside/live among them.” Among is literally “in middle of,” which perhaps insists on the fact that they lived right alongside each other. We might say “in the midst of” or “along with.” This is an important statement because the LORD had prohibited intermixing with these peoples.

The repetition of the city name Gezer may emphasize its status, but in many languages it will be better to eliminate the repetition by using a substitute expression, such as “in that place” or “there.”

For this verse we might say:

• Nor did the tribe of Ephraim drive out the Canaanites from the city of Gezer. The Canaanites continued to live right there alongside them.

• The descendants of Ephraim could not drive the Canaanites out from Gezer [either], so the Canaanites continued to live among them.

Quoted with permission from Zogbo, Lynell and Ogden, Graham S. A Handbook on Judges. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2019. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Judges 1:30

Zebulun did not drive out the inhabitants of Kitron, or the inhabitants of Nahalol: Unlike the previous verse, this verse does not begin with the Hebrew waw conjunction, showing a slight break in the narration. We could begin a new paragraph here and perhaps say “As for the tribe/people/clan of Zebulun….” Zebulun was Jacob’s tenth son, born to Leah (Gen 30.19-20). His descendants made up a small tribe that occupied the territory in the western hills north of the Jezreel Valley (verse 19.10-16). However, like the other Israelite tribes, the soldiers of Zebulun could not drive out the local population. Two towns, Kitron and Nahalol, are mentioned as having inhabitants who could not be driven out. The local Canaanite population continued to live in these towns, though eventually some of them became part of the forced labor working force. For did not drive out, see verse 1.19.

But the Canaanites dwelt among them: See comments on verse 1.29. Some see the waw conjunction rendered but as introducing a contrast. However, we might also say “And” or “So.” Another approach would be to omit the conjunction and simply say “The Canaanites continued to live among them.”

And became subject to forced labor is literally “and they were [or, became] to forced labor.” The Hebrew waw conjunction at the beginning of this clause seems to introduce additional information. We might say “and the people of Zebulun forced the Canaanites to work for them” or “and they were forced to work for the people of Zebulun.” NET Bible says “and were forced to do hard labor.” For forced labor, see verse 1.28.

Translation models for this verse are:

• As for the tribe of Zebulun, they did not drive out those living in Kitron and Nahalol. So the Canaanites continued to live among them, though eventually the tribe of Zebulun reduced them to forced labor.

• As well, the people of Zebulun were not able to remove the inhabitants of Kitron and Nahalol. So the Canaanites continued to live among them, but the people of Zebulun [eventually] subjected them to forced labor.

Quoted with permission from Zogbo, Lynell and Ogden, Graham S. A Handbook on Judges. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2019. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Judges 1:31

Asher did not drive out the inhabitants …: As in the previous verse, there is no Hebrew waw conjunction to begin this verse. A new paragraph can begin here with “As for the tribe of Asher, they did not…,” “The tribe of Asher, too, did not…,” or “Neither were the people of Asher able to….” Asher was Jacob’s eighth son, born to Leah’s servant Zilpah (Gen 30.12-13). The territory assigned to the descendants of Asher was located to the northwest of Zebulun, on the coastal plain extending from Mount Carmel north toward present-day. For did not drive out, see verse 1.19; for inhabitants see verse 1.11.

Though the warriors from the tribe of Asher attacked a number of towns (seven are listed here), they were not able to drive out the inhabitants from any of them. It is possible that they were not as capable in battle as the local people (verse 1.19). Interestingly, in this verse the typical Hebrew repetition is absent, since inhabitants is only mentioned twice with the first two cities, rather than all of them.

The seven towns joined together by the Hebrew waw conjunction are:

Acco: a coastal town a few kilometers north of Carmel
Sidon: another coastal town 40 kilometers (25 miles) north of Tyre
Ahlab: a town in Asherite territory also mentioned in verse 19.29
Achzib: a town 13 kilometers (8 miles) north of Acco
Helbah: an unknown town
Aphik: a town thought to be near present-day Haifa
Rehob: an unknown town

Translators will have to transliterate each of these names. There is a textual problem concerning the name Ahlab. In verse 19.29 the Hebrew has “Meheleb,” but Revised Standard Version writes “Mahalab.” Here Hebrew Old Testament Text Project recommends “Mahlab,” so translators will have to decide which form to follow.

Translators should use a natural way of conjoining names in their language. Some languages will say “and” while others will prefer “or,” as in Revised Standard Version. In some languages it may be better to begin this verse with the names of the towns as follows:

• Not in Acco, not in Sidon, nor Mahlab, Achzib, Helbah, Aphik or Rehob, in none of these places were the people of Asher able to drive out any of the inhabitants.

Quoted with permission from Zogbo, Lynell and Ogden, Graham S. A Handbook on Judges. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2019. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Judges 1:32

But (as a rendering of the Hebrew waw conjunction) seems too strong at this point. “And so” may be more appropriate. Other possibilities are “Thus” (Revised English Bible) and “So” (New Jerusalem Bible, New Jewish Publication Society’s Tanakh).

The Asherites dwelt among the Canaanites, the inhabitants of the land: Here there is yet another example of the “bad to worse” scenario so typical of this book. In the preceding verses the Canaanites are said to live among the Israelites, but here the situation is reversed, with the Asherites said to be dwelling among the Canaanites! This way of expressing things could also reflect the fact that the descendants of Asher were very few in number. Whatever the explanation, the storyteller has shifted viewpoints and this tribe seems worse off than the others. The order of presentation highlights the fact that it is the Canaanites, and not the Asherites, who are the inhabitants of the land—the land that was supposedly promised to this tribe of Israel. The long list of cities cited in the previous verse also emphasizes the fact that these people have consistently failed to do what God requested of them. For the Canaanites, see verse 1.1; for inhabitants see verse 1.11. Contemporary English Version‘s translation “and the Asher tribe lived with Canaanites all around them” is particularly effective.

For they did not drive them out is repeated from the beginning of verse 1.31, enclosing this short unit in an inclusio. The Hebrew particle ki rendered for introduces the reason the two peoples are living together, though this particle could also be taken as an emphatic marker, rendered “Indeed.” For did not drive … out, see verse 1.19.

Quoted with permission from Zogbo, Lynell and Ogden, Graham S. A Handbook on Judges. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2019. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .

Translation commentary on Judges 1:33

Naphtali did not drive out the inhabitants …: Naphtali was Jacob’s sixth son and the second son born to Bilhah, the servant of Rachel (Gen 30.7-8). The territory assigned to the tribe of Naphtali was east of Asher and northwest of the Sea of Galilee. For did not drive out, see verse 1.19; for inhabitants see verse 1.11.

The towns of Beth-shemesh and Beth-anath were almost certainly religious centers. Beth-shemesh means “house of the sun,” possibly related to the sun god, while Beth-anath means “house of Anath,” a Canaanite female divinity. Some versions treat these names as one word, while others insert a hyphen as Revised Standard Version here. Because they are foreign names and difficult to pronounce, a hyphenated form would probably make reading easier. Translators might consider translating at least parts of these names, if this helps readers to better understand the text.

But dwelt among the Canaanites, the inhabitants of the land: See verse 1.32. Like all the other tribes, the tribe of Naphtali did not drive out the inhabitants of these localities. More importantly, like Asher, this tribe dwelt among the Canaanites, instead of the other way around. There is the same emphasis on the Canaanites being the inhabitants of the land.

Nevertheless the inhabitants of Beth-shemesh and of Beth-anath became subject to forced labor for them: The Hebrew waw conjunction introduces this final clause, rendered well here as nevertheless. We could also say “however.” Even though the text does not say the tribe of Naphtali became stronger or more numerous (compare verse 1.28), this tribe eventually was able to oblige the Canaanites to work for them. For forced labor, see verse 1.28.

Quoted with permission from Zogbo, Lynell and Ogden, Graham S. A Handbook on Judges. (UBS Helps for Translators). Miami: UBS, 2019. For this and other handbooks for translators see here .